Over the last few months I've been cross-posting a lot less between Mastodon and Twitter.
When I first started on Mastodon last fall, I'd sometimes post to both networks. I'd reformat things slightly if I needed to fit a pair of 280-character tweets and a single 500-character toot. (I've long thought that if something takes more than two posts to say on a platform, that's not the right platform for it.) I'd often linkblog to Twitter, Mastodon and Facebook all at once.
But as I've shifted more toward Mastodon being my main social network, and Twitter being where I go in a private window to see what people are saying about politics, retweet a few items, and then leave, I've been posting completely different things to each site. These days, cross-posts between the two are almost non-existent.
So What am I Still Cross-Posting?
- Photos across Instagram, Pixelfed and Mastodon, depending on the type of photo.
- Occasional photos or text posts to my blog, if I decide they're significant enough to keep findable or if they fit with a recurring topic.
Plus I'm automatically pushing links to Twitter (and sometimes Tumblr) from:
- Flickr albums.
- Blog posts.
- Instagram photos.
- Randomly-chosen "flashbacks" from my blog a couple of times a week.
I realized: When I'm not using it actively, Twitter has basically become a dumping ground for me to link to what I do elsewhere on the net.
I don't think that would fly in the Fediverse. At least not on Mastodon. Maybe if the auto-posts were all unlisted, or on a secondary account.
ActivityPub: Boosting Instead
As the Fediverse grows to encompass more types of networks, we'll be able to boost instead of cross-posting. Right now I can post this article on a Plume instance and boost it to Mastodon, bringing it into the world of short status updates. In the very near future, I'll be able to do the same with a photo on Pixelfed. (I sort of can now, but replies and follows don't work yet.)
Both networks can interact directly with the original post. It's not an isolated duplicate. And while it'll display as a link on Mastodon, the network will funnel actions back here. Someone who sees it on Mastodon can reply there, and the conversation will appear both on their Mastodon timeline and the comment thread on this post. And I think that's awesome.