This is the first entry in a series of articles I'm planning to write on giving and receiving criticism. I feel I'm pretty good at it, and I figured I'd share my thoughts on the subject. This isn't meant as a clear "do and don't" guide, but rather the start of a discussion on the subject. Everyone is unique, and the approach I favor might not work for everyone. Feel free to share your thoughts in the comments.
For starters, I thought I'd talk about understanding intent. This, to me, is the first thing one should do when criticizing any sort of creative work. I first learned this the hard way years ago, back when I was active in the fanfiction scene. I read a story that was very much centered on long, over-the-top fight scenes. I found it frustrating to read, and told the author as much, that he should cut some of the fights and instead focus on character development.
The reply I got was eye-opening. The author argued that the battles were the entire point. He was a fan of shows like Dragon Ball and wanted to re-create that genre in his story. He explained that this is what his fans wanted and that I completely missed the point.
That got me thinking. I hadn't really been criticizing the story, but rather its genre. Looking back at the comments I left, I never really thought about what the author tried to accomplish, but rather projected my own preferences on the story. That made my feedback useless. Upon realizing this, I apologized to the author, and that was that.
I learned the same lesson again, but from an author's perspective with my current project, Opt Out. In short, the book deals with the dangers of invasive proprietary technology. It's heavily influenced by classic anticipation science-fiction like 1984 or Brave New World as well as more modern takes on issues of technology and surveillance such as Black Mirror or Cory Doctorow's Little Brother.
I decided to try something different for Opt Out when it was the time to get feedback. Instead of picking one or two trusted proofreaders, I sent it to as many people as possible. While I received some good, constructive feedback, I also got some pretty disheartening feedback. Not wanting to disregard anything, I actually tried re-writing the first chapter in a way that would satisfy my most severe critic.
The end result was disastrous. I didn't recognize my characters, everything felt flat. It no longer felt like my story. The problem was that in rewriting so heavily, I'd lost track of my initial intent for the story and characters. The feedback that rewrite had been based on wasn't as much directed at what I wrote, but rather my intention behind it. In fact, the person who gave me that criticism disagreed with many of the principles behind Opt Out. She even admitted as much before starting the book.
Again, the issue was similar. The criticism I'd gotten missed my intent. I should say that this is completely natural. We all tend to project our own vision onto whatever form of expression we come in contact with. Many artistic projects take advantage of this by being vague and allowing people to project themselves. Video games are especially good at this. This is the primary reason why so many iconic video game characters never speak.
Regardless of how much room there is for projection, every creative endeavor has an intent behind it. Before giving criticism, I always take the time to try and understand that intent. Is the author trying to make me laugh? Are they trying to make me reconsider something I take for granted, or just to give me some form of escapism? How do they want me to feel about their characters or their setting? If I have no idea, I point it out.
It's always a good idea to have a discussion about such things. Remember that when someone asks for criticism, they end goal is to improve their work. It's perfectly fine to ask what the point of the work is, who it's aimed for, or what message they're trying to convey. It's also perfectly fine to let them know that their intention isn't something you understand. It's okay to decline if you feel like you can't offer feedback that's in line with the intent.
I should point out that sharing your own vision of the story is fine. Giving criticism is first and foremost about giving your own impression, after all. Sometimes, a scene just doesn't work, or a character brings nothing to the story. Sometimes, the story feels very disconnected from its intent or conveys something completely different by mistake. Just remember that when someone asks you for criticism, they're not asking you to rewrite the story in your image. Understanding intent is one of the keys to a good working relationship. It applies to the story as a whole, as well as characters, scenes, even individual lines of dialogue.
Hope you all enjoyed this. As I pointed out earlier, I'm hoping to make this the first of a series of articles on the subject.
Comments
March 25, 2023 07:04
Gee… I translate writes on a similar to issue, be that as it may I never went by your blog. I added it to populars additionally i’ll be your reliable preliminary. สล็อตเว็บใหญ่
February 22, 2023 06:10
Here at this site amazingly the basic material gathering so everybody can value an incredible arrangement. https://toto40.com
February 24, 2023 10:27
A decent blog dependably concocts new and energizing data and keeping in mind that understanding I have feel that this blog is truly have each one of those quality that qualify a blog to be a one. ufabet
February 28, 2023 15:18
I am genuinely thankful to the holder of this site page who has shared this splendid section at this place cfa level 1 review sheet
February 28, 2023 15:34
Link daftar situs slot server indonesia resmi dan gacor no 1 mudah menang maxwin 2023 dari provider pay4d. slot indonesia tergacor mudah maxwin
March 2, 2023 14:43
This post is extremely radiant. I extremely like this post. It is outstanding amongst other posts that I ve read in quite a while. Much obliged for this better than average post. I truly value it! 카지노사이트
March 5, 2023 05:30
Link situs slot 1000 server luar negeri kamboja, thailand, amerika, singapore, malaysia, vietnam, filipina tergacor dan terpercaya no 1 mudah menang maxwin petir x500 rtp winrate tertinggi. situs slot 1000
March 6, 2023 12:53
This post is extremely radiant. I extremely like this post. It is outstanding amongst other posts that I ve read in quite a while. Much obliged for this better than average post. I truly value it! migliori stampanti 3d professionali
March 8, 2023 14:47
The site is tenderly balanced and saved as much as date. So it should be, an obligation of appreciation is all together to offer this to us. Kansas City web development
March 13, 2023 15:11
Just unadulterated magnificence from you here. I have never expected something not as much as this from you and you have not baffled me by any extend of the creative energy. I accept you will keep the quality work going on. เว็บสล็อตแตกง่าย
May 14, 2023 04:01
Kongregate - an online gaming portal that features a wide range of games, including casual and indie games, as well as multiplayer games. 토토사이트 추천
May 14, 2023 04:25
Kongregate - an online gaming portal that features a wide range of games, including casual and indie games, as well as multiplayer games. 토토사이트 검증
April 10, 2023 09:17
Mmm.. awesome to be here in your article or post, whatever, I figure I should moreover lock in for my own particular site like I see some extraordinary and invigorated working in your site. เว็บพนันออนไลน์เว็บตรง ไม่ผ่านเอเย่นต์
April 11, 2023 06:53
bocoran slot gacor paling akurat dan terupdate untuk info rtp live slot Pragmatic Play, Spadegaming, Habanero, PG Soft, Slot88. rtp live
June 2, 2023 11:08
At Rajendra Civil Law Firm, they understand that each case is unique and requires a tailored approach. That’s why they take the time to listen to their clients and understand their individual needs. Their team of skilled advocates for civil cases will work tirelessly to ensure that you get the best possible outcome. Top Attorneys for Civil Litigation
May 4, 2023 16:38
Brand protection is a critical aspect of any business strategy, and one of the most effective ways to achieve this is through trademark registration. If you are in Chennai, Rajendra Law Office is your trusted partner for trademark application and brand protection. Here are some reasons why: Trademark Application
June 21, 2023 19:09
검증된 파워볼사이트 를 찾으신다면 eos파워볼사이트 가 있는 파워볼사이트추천 에서 파워볼 을 즐기시길 바랍니다. 5년 이상 운영된 메이저업체 이며 지금까지 많은분들께 사랑받은 안전한파워볼사이트 입니다. 파워볼사이트
November 26, 2023 15:48
I’m a caregiver for my elderly parents, and medication call reminder has been a lifesaver. It’s helped me make sure that my parents are taking their medication as prescribed.
November 8, 2023 22:32
I recently discovered flangessteel.com , the online store of Flanges Steel, and I’m thrilled with the variety of flanges they offer. When it comes to reliable flange solutions, they are the experts.
November 17, 2023 22:42
Navigating the intricacies of an Egypt residence permit can be overwhelming, but Work Permit Egypt was my guiding light. Their expertise and commitment to client success are evident throughout the process. I highly recommend their services to anyone in need of a reliable partner for their residence permit journey in Egypt.
August 25, 2022 09:04
Good story! Here is some useful information. Go to 2 player games to support your search for online multiplayer games by browsing their selection of game genres and topics. Participate in the game alone or with friends.
May 10, 2023 03:47
Amazon also accepts other barcode types such as EAN (International Article Number), ISBN (International Standard Book Number), and ASIN (Amazon Standard Identification Number) for specific types of products. upc barcode
May 10, 2023 03:53
Amazon also accepts other barcode types such as EAN (International Article Number), ISBN (International Standard Book Number), and ASIN (Amazon Standard Identification Number) for specific types of products. upc barcode
May 10, 2023 03:54
Amazon also accepts other barcode types such as EAN (International Article Number), ISBN (International Standard Book Number), and ASIN (Amazon Standard Identification Number) for specific types of products. upc barcode
October 6, 2022 15:48
In fact, this influenced them to think what diverse activities are valuable for those of us who end up all over the place or have confined rigging decisions. 토토사이트 추천
October 3, 2022 12:26
This is a fabulous post I seen by virtue of offer it. It is genuinely what I expected to see look for in future you will continue subsequent to sharing such an extraordinary post. 바둑이온라인
September 22, 2022 05:19
Sceneca Residence by MCC Land. Hotline 61004343. Get Discounts, Direct Developer Price, Floor Plan, Price List, Brochure & More.sceneca residence condo
September 22, 2022 16:23
Freehold condo at draycott park. Hotline 61004343. Get Discounts, Direct Developer Price, Floor Plan, Price List, Brochure & More.one draycott condo
September 26, 2022 06:24
Its most exceedingly awful piece was that the item just worked intermittently and the data was not exact. You plainly canot go up against anyone about what you have found if the information isn’t right.hartco clip gun
September 27, 2022 07:22
英国、澳大利亚、美国、加拿大,新西兰等国广大留学生致以最为优质的论文代写、代考、作业代写、网课代修以及其他学术辅导工作。Excellent Due的团队写手由于合作形式多样化;功底扎实且经验丰富;研究思路新颖奇特;所以写手阵容空前强大,可根据各国地方文化、语言特色、写作方式与习惯的不同,制定对口论文级作业代写。网课代修可保成绩,任何作业保证100%原创,100%通过。提交给您之前初稿Turnitin UK或Turnitin国际版最新反抄袭系统检测,完美达到作业要求。美国论文代写
October 9, 2022 07:14
Gangaur Realtech is a professionally overseen association having some expertise in land administrations where coordinated administrations are given by experts to its customers looking for expanded an incentive by owning, involving or putting resources into land. 스웨디시
September 29, 2022 13:11
To an extraordinary degree beautiful and fascinating post. I was filtering for this sort of data and relished the experience of looking at this one. 토토커뮤니티
October 5, 2022 13:09
Your online diaries propel more each else volume is so captivating further serviceable It chooses me happen for pull back repeat. I will in a blaze grab your reinforce to stay instructed of any updates. 홀덤사이트
October 9, 2022 10:41
I no uncertainty esteeming each and every bit of it. It is an amazing site and superior to anything normal give. I need to grateful. Marvelous work! Every one of you complete an unfathomable blog, and have some extraordinary substance. Keep doing stunning. 꽁머니 토토
October 5, 2022 14:54
In fact, this influenced them to think what diverse activities are valuable for those of us who end up all over the place or have confined rigging decisions. anti insect netting
October 8, 2022 06:59
I am checking for and I have to post a remark that “The substance of your post is excellent” Great work! 토토사이트
October 6, 2022 10:04
There you can download for nothing, see the first of these information. 꽁머니
October 9, 2022 16:30
Information on drinking song and dance karaoke in Incheon, Korea.인천룸싸롱
October 6, 2022 10:54
stunning, glorious, I was thinking about how to cure skin disturbance routinely. likewise, discovered your site by google, took in a ton, now i’m to some degree clear. I’ve bookmark your site and also join rss. keep us resuscitated. 바둑이
October 15, 2022 06:39
A commitment of gratefulness is all together for the educational and satisfying post, obviously in your blog everything is unprecedented.. 먹튀사이트
October 10, 2022 14:18
staggering, marvelous, I was considering how to cure skin irritation regularly. also, found your site by google, took in a ton, now i’m to some degree clear. I’ve bookmark your site and moreover incorporate rss. keep us revived. สล็อตฝากถอนไม่มีขั้นต่ำ
October 10, 2022 18:03
The writer is fiery about obtaining wooden furniture on the web and his examination about best wooden furniture has understood the arrangement of this article. สล็อตออนไลน์888
October 11, 2022 06:14
I am awed by the information that you have on this blog. It exhibits how well you appreciate this subject. 먹튀사이트
October 11, 2022 06:44
Much obliged to you for your post, I search for such article along time, today I discover it at long last. this post give me heaps of prompt it is extremely helpful for me. 토토
October 15, 2022 09:55
You re in motivation behind truth a without defect site administrator. The site stacking speed is shocking. It kind of feels that you’re doing any unmistakable trap. Furthermore, The substance are ideal gem. you have completed a marvelous activity with respect to this issue! 토토추천
October 11, 2022 12:11
This is in like way an OK post which I extremely invigorating examining. It isn’t each day that I have the likelihood to see something like this.. 꽁머니 5000
October 15, 2022 15:33
This is a fabulous post I seen by virtue of offer it. It is genuinely what I expected to see look for in future you will continue subsequent to sharing such an extraordinary post. 토토커뮤니티 추천
October 12, 2022 08:45
General visits recorded here are the most easy system to esteem your imperativeness, which is the motivation behind why I am taking off to the site conventional, examining for new, interesting information. Many, favor your heart! Cube Culture USA
October 12, 2022 18:49
Its most exceedingly awful piece was that the item just worked intermittently and the data was not exact. You plainly canot go up against anyone about what you have found if the information isn’t right. ดูหนังออนไลน์ฟรี
October 29, 2022 15:28
General visits recorded here are the most easy system to esteem your imperativeness, which is the motivation behind why I am taking off to the site conventional, examining for new, interesting information. Many, favor your heart! 먹튀폴리스
October 30, 2022 06:25
Finnish marketing site Supermarkkinointi.com. Hakukoneoptimointi SEO
November 6, 2022 07:54
I expect you to thank for your time of this phenomenal read!!! I definately welcome each and every piece of it and I have you bookmarked to look at new stuff of your blog a specific essential read blog! 온라인바카라
November 4, 2022 11:20
Stunning learning and I get a kick out of the chance to give this sort of data to my sidekicks and want they like it they why I do 온라인바카라
November 4, 2022 13:23
@Adilkhatri this one is a legit markov bot
November 5, 2022 18:09
I ought to declare scarcely that its astonishing! The blog is instructive additionally dependably manufacture astonishing entitys. dive puerto morelos
November 4, 2022 12:16
Mmm.. amazing to be here in your article or post, whatever, I figure I ought to also secure for my own specific site like I see some phenomenal and stimulated working in your site. 강남란제리
October 19, 2022 10:00
About Whiskey Shirt Karaoke in Gangnam, South Korea. 셔츠룸
November 2, 2022 07:06
Introduction to karaoke where you can eat whiskey in Suwon, Korea. 수원룸싸롱
November 19, 2022 13:10
staggering, marvelous, I was considering how to cure skin irritation regularly. also, found your site by google, took in a ton, now i’m to some degree clear. I’ve bookmark your site and moreover incorporate rss. keep us revived. 카지노사이트
November 26, 2022 04:56
This webpage and I consider this web site is amazingly informational ! Keep on setting up! 꽁머니 사이트
November 20, 2022 10:46
llo there mates, it is inconceivable formed piece totally portrayed, continue with the considerable work dependably. iecetech.org
November 20, 2022 18:51
Mmm.. awesome to be here in your article or post, whatever, I figure I should moreover lock in for my own particular site like I see some extraordinary and invigorated working in your site. Apps To Meet People
November 27, 2022 09:19
Here you will realize what is vital, it gives you a connection to an intriguing site page: things to do in jamaica
November 27, 2022 09:20
Here you will realize what is vital, it gives you a connection to an intriguing site page: things to do in jamaica
November 22, 2022 04:23
It’s extremely educational and you are clearly exceptionally proficient around there. You have opened my eyes to differing sees on this point with fascinating and strong substance. winslot
November 22, 2022 05:18
I incline toward simply phenomenal assets - you will see these individuals in: mesin slot
November 26, 2022 09:28
I require you to thank for your period of this extraordinary read!!! I definately welcome every last bit of it and I have you bookmarked to take a gander at new stuff of your blog a certain prerequisite read blog! 인터넷바카라
November 22, 2022 05:29
Here you will realize what is vital, it gives you a connection to an intriguing site page: betslot
November 15, 2022 07:27
llo there mates, it is unfathomable formed piece totally delineated, continue with the amazing work continually. 먹튀검증
November 22, 2022 06:28
I can suggest essentially not too bad and even dependable tips, accordingly see it: hokiplay
November 22, 2022 07:19
Such destinations are imperative since they give a huge measurement of valuable data … mauslot88
November 15, 2022 11:17
I should state just that its magnificent! The blog is instructive and dependably create astonishing things. 스포츠토토사이트
December 11, 2022 06:23
Sushi Restaurant, Asian Food Restaurant, Best Restaurant Baden Baden. chinesisches restaurant baden baden
November 24, 2022 15:17
An obligation of appreciation is all together for the informational and pleasing post, plainly in your blog everything is extraordinary.. luchthaven vervoer
November 22, 2022 09:29
staggering, marvelous, I was considering how to cure skin irritation regularly. also, found your site by google, took in a ton, now i’m to some degree clear. I’ve bookmark your site and moreover incorporate rss. keep us revived. neon signs
November 27, 2022 07:23
This is a great post I seen because of offer it. It is truly what I needed to see seek in future you will proceed after sharing such a magnificent post. jamaica all inclusive resorts
November 22, 2022 09:31
A debt of gratitude is in order for composing such a decent article, I staggered onto your blog and read a couple of post. I like your style of composing… sgtoto
November 22, 2022 09:36
It has completely climbed to crown Singapore’s southern shores and without a doubt set her on the general guide of private remarkable core interests. Regardless I scored the a more prominent number of focuses than I ever have in a season for GS. I figure you would be not capable discover some individual with a relative consistency I have had amid the time so I am content with that. eratogel
November 25, 2022 04:38
llo there mates, it is inconceivable formed piece totally portrayed, continue with the considerable work dependably. 우리카지노
November 18, 2022 05:26
Size - First measure the room and determine how big is rug you desire. You will find no set rules for placing a carpet in a room. Many people prefer a small rug in a large room. Some want to observe that the rug fits the room to the precise size. People usually compromise on size first. When they find an antique rug they fall deeply in love with centered on its colors, design, price or style, they’re very ready to compromise on size. The price of new rugs is dependant on square footage. The bigger the rug is, the higher priced it will be. However, this really is incorrect with antique rugs being that they are individually evaluated predicated on many factors. As an example, it is not unusual for an antique rug (5’x8’) to be sold in Christies London for $10 million. Rugs
November 18, 2022 14:27
staggering, marvelous, I was considering how to cure skin irritation regularly. also, found your site by google, took in a ton, now i’m to some degree clear. I’ve bookmark your site and moreover incorporate rss. keep us revived. แทงไฮโล
December 11, 2022 08:27
Bonanza138 merupakan daftar situs judi slot online gacor dan terpercaya di Indonesia serta 10 istilah dalam agen slot resmi dengan RTP live slot tertinggi. https://ncaa-tournament.si.com/
November 28, 2022 06:05
The site is tenderly balanced and saved as much as date. So it should be, an obligation of appreciation is all together to offer this to us. cfa study material level 1
November 28, 2022 10:15
General visits recorded here are the most easy system to esteem your imperativeness, which is the motivation behind why I am taking off to the site conventional, examining for new, interesting information. Many, favor your heart! สล็อต888 เครดิตฟรี ไม่ต้องฝาก ถอนได้
November 28, 2022 10:15
I obviously esteeming each and every piece of it and I have you bookmarked to look at new stuff you post. สล็อต888 เครดิตฟรี ไม่ต้องฝาก ถอนได้
November 28, 2022 10:15
I obviously esteeming each and every piece of it and I have you bookmarked to look at new stuff you post. สล็อต888 เครดิตฟรี ไม่ต้องฝาก ถอนได้
November 28, 2022 16:28
Premium Quality at an affordable price. Don’t overpay for custom neon signs. Create your own personalized neon sign now! twitch neon sign
December 1, 2022 15:38
I am genuinely thankful to the holder of this site page who has shared this splendid section at this place vaginal warts
December 14, 2022 17:52
it’s to a great degree cool blog. Interfacing is incredibly profitable thing.you have really had any kind of effect สล็อต888
December 3, 2022 14:39
Just unadulterated magnificence from you here. I have never expected something not as much as this from you and you have not baffled me by any extend of the creative energy. I accept you will keep the quality work going on. https://tools.seohelp.me/
December 5, 2022 14:07
Premium quality at an affordable price. The UK’s most affordable supplier of custom neon signs. personalized neon signs
December 5, 2022 15:48
부산 해운대고구려 정찰제 룸싸롱 1위 추천 부산고구려
December 5, 2022 16:05
If you should be considering expanding your business to online ordering you can easily create a website along with your menu, prices and an order form to process credit and debit card purchases with restaurant POS software. takeaway Online ordering website
December 5, 2022 19:13
The site is tenderly balanced and saved as much as date. So it should be, an obligation of appreciation is all together to offer this to us. 윈조이머니상
December 7, 2022 13:05
I get a kick out of the chance to suggest only fine in addition to proficient data and realities, thus see it: แทงบอล 10 บาท ผ่านเว็บพนันบอล
December 7, 2022 19:48
That got me thinking nearest chase bank I hadn’t really been criticizing the story, but rather its genre. Looking back at the comments I left, I never really ..
January 2, 2023 08:14
Decent data, profitable and fantastic plan, as offer well done with smart thoughts and ideas, loads of extraordinary data and motivation, both of which I require, on account of offer such a supportive data here. เว็บสล็อตใหม่ล่าสุด
January 2, 2023 11:14
I can suggest essentially not too bad and even dependable tips, accordingly see it: Roma Slot
January 2, 2023 18:59
Good subject, comparative writings are I don’t know whether they are on a par with your work out. สล็อตทุกค่าย
January 28, 2023 13:46
I am genuinely thankful to the holder of this site page who has shared this splendid section at this place 168bet
January 5, 2023 05:29
Captivating post. I Have Been contemplating about this issue, so an obligation of appreciation is all together to post. Completely cool post.It ’s greatly extraordinarily OK and Useful post.Thanks matka
January 12, 2023 13:03
The site is tenderly balanced and saved as much as date. So it should be, an obligation of appreciation is all together to offer this to us. เว็บพนันออนไลน์เว็บตรง ไม่ผ่านเอเย่นต์
April 3, 2023 14:46
Situs judi JDB slot indonesia game terpercaya paling gacor 100%. Daftar segera di link bo jdb gaming terbaik deposit pulsa. JDB slot terpercaya
February 1, 2023 13:27
Just unadulterated magnificence from you here. I have never expected something not as much as this from you and you have not baffled me by any extend of the creative energy. I accept you will keep the quality work going on. เกมสล็อตค่าย PG ใหม่ล่าสุด
March 21, 2023 09:02
The site is tenderly balanced and saved as much as date. So it should be, an obligation of appreciation is all together to offer this to us. เว็บสล็อตแตกบ่อย
March 21, 2023 10:07
Your websites facilitate all the more each else volume is so engaging further serviceable It chooses me occur for withdraw reprise. I will in a split second snatch your rss channel to remain educated of any updates. เกมไพ่ป๊อกเด้ง
April 7, 2023 12:06
Slot gates of gatot kaca x500 di bo slot gacor sedunia dengan jaminan pasti maxwin. https://gamesenzo.com/